Sell My Car Privately or Trade It In?

Many individuals that want to sell their car are either looking to trade it in on a different car or simply get it sold for the cash. There are benefits and drawbacks to both approaches that should be weighed depending on the situation. If the seller is not interested in acquiring a new car then using it as a trade-in will obviously not be an option.

Selling Privately

There are some common mistakes made by a seller when trying to move their used car. They will often perform research on prices through Blue Book values and look at the Manufacturer's Suggested Retail Price (MSRP) to come to a price for their used vehicle. This is actually not a good approach.

People generally buy used cars privately because they do not want to shell out dealer prices on the vehicle. Pricing like a dealer means that used vehicle could be sitting much longer than anticipated. A person buying from a dealer can look forward to additional warranties or even the vehicle being factory or dealer certified before being put on the lot.

A privately sold vehicle will not have those extra amenities. Thus, the price of the vehicle should reflect that. Perform some research on similar vehicles being sold in the area privately and through dealers. Those are far more accurate metrics when compared against each other to come to a reasonable asking price.

Trading It In

The other option for most sellers will be to trade it in to a dealer to get some credit on a different vehicle. The same pitfall of overestimating the value of a trade-in is one to be avoided. The dealer needs to turn a profit to stay in business. If they buy and sell according to suggested values they will not be in business very long.

There are some steps you can take to help gain some additional value on your transaction. Do not discuss the trade-in until after you are done negotiating a price on the vehicle you are interested in. The sales representative will likely inquire if there will be a trade-in early in the discussion. As a standard method of operation, a dealer will generally negotiate more favorable terms from their end when a trade-in is involved.

The negotiated price of the vehicle being bought will typically be added with a trade-in to help offset some of the cost the dealer is sacrificing. Yes, they will eventually make money off of that trade-in. They need to operate under the assumption it will not sell in the near future.

Selling a car privately or trading it in will largely depend on the personal circumstances of the seller. Either approach can work out well with the right understanding of the vehicle's value and how a potential buyer is viewing it. Understanding the mentality of the buyer will allow a seller to more easily facilitate their sale.

Back To Sell My Car Articles